| Conference | Player | School |
| Mid-State | Kia Brewington | Jordan-Matthews |
| Logan Keiper | Jordan-Matthews | |
| Kelly Zelaya | Jordan-Matthews | |
| Justin Kirkman | Jordan-Matthews | |
| Nathan Woolard | Jordan-Matthews | |
| Jared Hurt | Graham | |
| Tanner Cook | Graham | |
| Ian Marrow | Graham | |
| Kasey Withers | Graham | |
| Dillon Waite | Providence Grove | |
| Eric Johnson | Providence Grove | |
| Blake Covington | Reidsville | |
| Austin Boone | Reidsville | |
| Geoffrey Haigler | Reidsville | |
| Jake McLamb | Reidsville | |
| Patrick Donovant | Reidsville | |
| Honorable Mention | ||
| David Kongpaseuth | Graham | |
| Joel McMath | Jordan-Matthews | |
| Eli Routh | Providence Grove | |
| Carl Holder | Reidsville | |
| Zack Haynes | Reidsville | |
| PAC-6 | Eric Lagueruela | Wheatmore |
| Avery Musgrave | Wheatmore | |
| Holden Sumner | Wheatmore | |
| Jordan McClure | Wheatmore | |
| Brennan Austin | Trinity | |
| Chase Pruitt | Trinity | |
| Alex Acuff | Trinity | |
| Austin Hancock | Trinity | |
| Kevin Beugger | High Point Andrews | |
| Tayyad Hussain | High Point Andrews | |
| James Wright | Randleman | |
| Michel Recendez | Randleman | |
| Mountain Valley | Evan Day | Wilkes Central |
| Miles Hubbard | Wilkes Central | |
| Garrettt Lakey | Wilkes Central | |
| Jesse Massucco | Wilkes Central | |
| Blake Goins | Forbush | |
| Daniel Poindexter | Forbush | |
| Tyler Reece | Forbush | |
| Taylor Sharpe | Forbush | |
| Nathan Hall | Starmount | |
| Denver Rakes | Starmount | |
| Waccamaw | Devin Cokely | Whiteville |
| Will Cannady | Whiteville | |
| Trey Nealey | Whiteville | |
| Carolina 10 | Zac Marion | Cedar Ridge |
| Matthew Dwinell | Cedar Ridge | |
| Thomas Delafield | Northwood | |
| Christian Manhard | Northwood | |
| Ryan Smith | Northwood | |
| Emerson Ellis | Durham School of the Arts | |
| J P Gemborys | Durham School of the Arts | |
| Gin Kang | Carrboro | |
| Pablo Calderon | Carrboro | |
| Erik Lutz | Cedar Ridge | |
| Drew Guerra | Durham School of the Arts | |
| Honorable Mention | ||
| Braden Karrigan | Carrboro | |
| Brandon Hutchison | Carrboro | |
| Gin Kang | Carrboro | |
| Aaron Hiller | Carrboro | |
| Josh Green | Carrboro | |
| Pablo Calderon | Carrboro | |
| Jacob Walters | South Granville | |
| Dylan Taylor | South Granville | |
| Tyler Ellis | South Granville | |
| Julian Alvarado | Granville Central | |
| Don Teasley | Granville Central | |
| Robbie Tepperberg | Durham School of the Arts | |
| Charles Relabit | Durham School of the Arts | |
| Eric Cross | Northwood | |
| Christian Manhard | Northwood | |
| Three Rivers | Brandon McDonald | Fairmont |
| Jeremy Jones | Fairmont | |
| Kendall Locklear | Fairmont | |
| Josh Clegg | St. Pauls | |
| Southern Piedmont | Matthew Ledford | Lincolnton |
| Jonathan Paulk | North Lincoln | |
| Stephen Harris | North Lincoln | |
| Evan Peaire | North Lincoln | |
| Tyler Mattner | East Lincoln | |
| Tyler Black | East Lincoln | |
| Dylan Sigmon | West Lincoln | |
| Western Highlands | Grant Buckner | Mountain Heritage |
| Ben Stockdale | Polk | |
| Bobby Decker | Charles D. Owen | |
| Eli Hile | Charles D. Owen | |
| Madison Alexander | Polk | |
| Christian Fahnley | Polk | |
| Central Carolina | Levi Bruff | Central Davidson |
| Evan Allred | Central Davidson | |
| Matt Fullbright | Central Davidson | |
| East Central | Tyler Biehl | Richlands |
Men's Tennis 2011 All-Conference 2-A